Friday, 10 April 2009

Race Play

You all need to go read this, here, right now. A frank discussion of race play between two Black people. Start at Part 1 and read the whole thing in order.

I do not have snazzy, witty commentary right now. I have some things floating in my head, especially as a white kinky person who dated a Black kinky one (in big letters I announce loudly that we NEVER DID RACE PLAY and did not have any kind of D/s relationship in either direction), but every time I try to write them down I rethink them.

So I'll just say that I do think it should be read and thought about. And that it especially should be read by the folks who seem to think that race play is always white tops' idea.

38 comments:

Clarisse Thorn said...

Thanks so much for posting this. Mollena Williams just came to Chicago and gave a Race Play workshop, and I MISSED IT because I had a fight with my ex that ended up screwing my entire schedule for that day. So I'm pleased to see that I can get her perspective here.

Clarisse Thorn said...

Followup comment, now that I've read the interview:

Ever since I started thinking about race play, I tried to imagine what might conceivably approach that level of transgression -- for me -- in my head (I am not trying to make an argument about what's "equivalently transgressive" for the entirety of American society).

For me, I think that one type of play that would feel as scandalous and scary as race play would be ... feminism play. Like, "You think you're such a feminist, but you're still doing this you bitch."

... I'm pretty sure I'm not interested in doing that, but I wonder if part of that is because I think it's TOO fucked up ....

Any thoughts welcome.

Trinity said...

"Ever since I started thinking about race play, I tried to imagine what might conceivably approach that level of transgression -- for me -- in my head (I am not trying to make an argument about what's "equivalently transgressive" for the entirety of American society)."

I'm not sure I think anything could be for me -- simply because I don't think I have anything approaching that kind of experience.

I do have a fantasy of forced feminization, of people dressing me up in frilly things and a long wig and makeup and "forcing" me to parade around the club. I sort of want to do this, just because I know that femininity is a personal minefield for me and I think it would probably be good for me to force myself to deal with my feelings about it.

But I don't know that I'd actually do it, because I wouldn't want people to not understand that that was a humiliation scene and tell me I was "pretty" and should do that more often -- a reaction I sometimes get from heteronormative folks when I look more feminine (and often feel deeply uncomfortable.)

I'd want to be sure people understand I'm presenting that way the bottom in a scene that might well prove really wrenching for me... and I worry that people wouldn't get that.

Clarisse said...

Ah, the "pretty" thing. I could write pages about that, but I spent my stolen work time commenting on this post that a friend directed me to: [ http://lesswrong.com/lw/ac/is_masochism_necessary/ ]

I'd be interested to see your thoughts. It's a different kind of community from the one that's usually telling us to "examine".

SnowdropExplodes said...

Thanks for posting the link - the whole article was fascinating reading.

I find the question of "what would be a similarly transgressive play?" to be fascinating. My first thought is feminised submission, which I just won't touch in r/l because too often it's presented a "forced feminisation" and humiliation: I really cannot see my feminine/female side as a source of humiliation, it's something that I am very proud to express. My fear is that too many people would see it and just think "humiliation", and then it would be broken for me.

The other thing would be something to do with my political or religious views: building a scene around the persecution of Christians by Soviet Russia (or indeed, Ancient Rome) could be simultaneously very hot and very troubling for me, for example - or indeed a scene based around persecution of communists by some ruling party.


BTW Just a thought, Trin: do you think it might work if you were prettified, but had a sign saying "Tomboy" around your neck? I'm thinking that this could be a form of roleplay "punishment" by (maybe) a strictly gender-role reinforcing girls' school. The idea behind this being that the sign would signal the roleplay element, and people would understand by it that "pretty" is not a desirable state for you?

Trinity said...

SD,

Thanks for that suggestion, but no, I don't think that would work for me.

Ernest Greene said...

First time here as a poster, though a frequent and fascinated reader. This conversation is just too interesting to resist.

It would be convenient if BDSM existed in a political and social vacuum in which issues like race and gender didn't intrude, but the hard-to-deny question is, would it exist as it does if that were actually the case? When this is thrown in our faces by hostile outsiders, it's perfectly natural to bristle at it, but fabsent the finger-wagging, it's still a nagging conundrum.

What those who criticize BDSM construct as its reification of stereotypes as something other than prejudicial when, in fact, that's what they are, I tend to see as the reclaiming of archetypes that may have been created by social injustices in their historical origins but that can be assigned new meanings within the confines of our shared imaginations.

For me, nothing is as problematic as the appropriation of Nazi symbolism in kink situations. As a Jew, seeing anyone in a Nazi uniform anywhere provokes instantaneous and visceral responses. However, as a uniform fetishist, I have no choice but to concede the Nazis their due when it comes to military couture. Dr. Hugo Boss definitely knew how to cut a tunic. But the idea of partying with people dressed as Nazis, even though I know they're absolutely not Nazis in any way whatsoever, squicks me out nonetheless.

I struggled with this contradiction for some time until I finally got to talk to a pair of lesbian players I'd seen at parties for years, generally in Nazi regalia. Turns out both were Jewish and found it amusing to picture how indignant actual Nazis would be at the notion of Jewish lesbians engaging in every perversion the Nazis sought to eradicate while wearing the sacred raiments of their aryan superiors. Could be just a rationalization, but it makes some sense to me.

Personally, I don't think I could ever do a role-playing scene involving Nazis, or one in which racist language was a required element of the script, but I can't see judging those who choose to do so for troubliing the minds of uninvolved parties. If we allow that the thrill of the forbidden is part of the allure of BDSM, what is more forbidden than bending the archetypal sources of our worst historical associations into the energizing of our sexual fantasies?

I think the key to getting comfortable with these kinds of preferences lies in giving the participants credit for having thought the implications through and concluded that, free of any real-world spill-over, they can deal with them. If the players themselves can, I don't see why the rest of us shouldn't.

Trinity said...

Ernest,

That's about the way I react to this myself. I don't know that I have much to add to what you say -- especially since I'm neither Jewish nor Black, so if I say "that never bothered me and always struck me as similar to any other 'creepy' kind of play" the response is always (and maybe rightly?) "but you're not a member of the oppressed group!"

I mean, I suppose there could be meaning to my utter lack of desire to what Clarisse, above, calls "feminism play." But even there, it doesn't offend me. There really are people who are Good Feminists but really want heavy humiliation and domination, so... *shrug*

I guess the closest thing in my life would be fetishizing of disability, and... perhaps weirdly, that doesn't bug me.

It could be the way I've seen it done most of the time, which is fetish models like Kumimonster posing in wheelchairs or with crutches and looking kind of like a creepy plastic doll.

Whether this reaction is sensible or not, it doesn't really feel to me like that reflects on me, as someone who has used plenty of those devices. If anything it reads more to me as a comment on the soullessness of technology, kind of like robot fetishism in a way.

Which is kind of odd, as I'm part of a movement where, well, assistive technology of whatever sort is normal, just there, like glasses or something. So there's a part of me that wonders if I "should" be offended -- like, shouldn't I be going "no, that's not really fascinating, it's just an alternate leg?"

But... well, first of all it's so unreal it doesn't feel personal to me. And second, well... someone did, once, look at my scars and call me a cyborg once, and it did hurt. I'm not sure that never exploring those stereotypes is good.

I mean, I don't think everyone should rush into doing so because I said so, and I understand totally why people wouldn't. But...

...eh. I guess for me I don't see it as different in kind from playing with something else that's dark and difficult. If I don't have problems with rape fantasy, or with the idea of humiliation play, I don't see why these other things are so wildly different in kind.

And I've always, personally, found the "Hitler would shit a brick, seeing this!" convincing. But again, I'm not sure I'm the person who has to be convinced.

Alexandra Erin said...

I don't think I would be able to do race play, but I'm at a place where that doesn't trigger feelings of squick or "OMGHOWCANYOUDOTHAT?"

I mean, my kink is gynophagic cannibalism scenarios... the scenarios frequently include elements of what might be termed "feminism play" or "patriarchy play". I'm not going to throw stones.

Cereus said...

For me, I think that one type of play that would feel as scandalous and scary as race play would be ... feminism play. Like, "You think you're such a feminist, but you're still doing this you bitch."

Actually... I've pretty much done exactly that. At the time it was pretty scary (although not necessarily in a bad way). But that's one of the main reasons why I can respond intellectually to these debates, or with anger or laughter - instead of wanting to crawl under a rock.

Anonymous said...

car insurance missouri I knew I was correct. My buddy and I placed a bet about which web site was superior. I thought your webpage was much better written, but she believed this article on trendy fashion tips was much better. We rounded up 5 loved ones memebers who had not seen either website before to examine them both over. Majority chose your site. Thanks for maintaing a excellent site. Mike , texas auto insurance

Apcalis said...

Look… here I am I have tried out things in the same manner as you described and guess what!!! I have been successful in taking up the challenge and fulfilling the endeavor finally!!! There cannot be anything better than this.

Caverta | Penegra

Anonymous said...

I just bought a car and I do not know which automobile insurance company is great and offers good offers. Can any one help me? Keep in mind I'm on a budget. Does any one know which is a good company in my situation?

Anonymous said...

Great website, looks very clean and organized. Keep up the good work! antibacterial Read a useful article about tramadol tramadol

sports handicapping software said...

This is an amazing blog post here.... I like your blog. Thanks very much for sharing such an amazing blog post.

Anonymous said...

Thank you a great deal intended for writing this. Mollena Williams merely stumbledBuy rs gold on Dallas along with afforded some sort of Contest Enjoy work shop, i Skipped This due to the fact I had a fight using the ex girlfriend or boyfriend in which ended up screwing out the whole schedule for that day. Consequently Now i am pleased to identifygw2 gold that I'm able to obtain the girl standpoint here.

Anonymous said...

Only 35 - Erectile Dysfunction Patients, Is This many Age? - Know the Numbers Erectile Dysfunction (Male Impotence) - Get to the many produces moreover situation [url=http://fortishealth.info/pharmacy/can-lexapro-cause-tremors-b8.html]can lexapro cause tremors[/url] Erectile Dysfunction: Some Troublesome Statistics and therefore the Viable Solutions

Anonymous said...

Erectile Dysfunction Treatments - What Type One Works the Best? Erectile dysfunction in Men [url=http://atriushealth.info/pharmacy/bronchitis-cipro-15.html]bronchitis cipro[/url] Lovemaking Dysfunction & Their Own Effects

Anonymous said...

What Causes Erectile Dysfunction and What Can You Do? Erectile Dysfunction: - Situation, Causes and Treatment [url=http://fortishealth.info/pharmacy/accutane-legal-in-wisconsin-17.html]accutane legal in wisconsin[/url] Chinese herbal remedies for Erectile Dysfunction - Discover the Herbal Treatment for Impotence

Anonymous said...

Know How You Cure Erectile Dysfunction Naturally With Herbal Supplements? 3 Causes of Erectile Dysfunction and Just how Erectile Dysfunction Tablets Can Help [url=http://budgiehealth.info/health/levitra-match-cf.html]levitra match[/url] Treat Impotence with Erectile Dysfunction Pills

Anonymous said...

Erectile Dysfunction - Is it Psychological? Erectile Dysfunction Treatment - Finding this That Works For You [url=http://proteahealth.info/pharma/clomid-boy-or-girl-91.html]clomid boy or girl[/url] Necessary Facts About Erectile dysfunction

Anonymous said...

What Is Erectile Dysfunction? ED Treatment- 5 Secrets to Naturally Treatment Erectile Disfunction [url=http://bricomedical.info/pharmacy/chemical-drug-nolvadex-structure-bc.html]chemical drug nolvadex structure[/url] Erectile Dysfunction Within The Human Sexual Response Cycle!

Anonymous said...

What VigRX Plus has to do with Erectile Dysfunction? Healing Erectile Dysfunction well In Prostate related gland Cancer malignancy Survivors: Appears Unachievable! [url=http://budgiehealth.info/health/nexium-safe-while-pregant-49.html]nexium safe while pregant[/url] Erectile Disorder Supplement - A Cure Without Line Effects!

Anonymous said...

Erectile Dysfunction Products - Which In Turn Ones Operate the Best? Precious Truths Regarding Herbal Treatments for Erectile Dysfunction [url=http://fortishealth.info/pharmacy/propecia-pill-4e.html]propecia pill[/url] Restoring Erectile Dysfunction the Easy Approach

Anonymous said...

A short list of the Medications That Cause Erectile Dysfunction? Various Causes And Techniques Of Determining Erectile Dysfunction [url=http://budgiehealth.info/health/ocd-tremor-lexapro-4f.html]ocd tremor lexapro[/url] Best Herbal Product for Erectile Dysfunction - Take Harder Erections

Anonymous said...

Are Safed Musli Capsules Helpful Having Curing Erectile Dysfunction? The Common Causes Of Erectile Dysfunction In Young Men [url=http://farmoshealth.info/pharm/patrick-adler-kamagra-generic-viagra-73.html]patrick adler kamagra generic viagra[/url] Azure Capsule Factfile: A Therapy For Erectile Dysfunction (Erectile Dysfunction)

Anonymous said...

Do Herbal Products for Penis Enlargement and Erectile Dysfunction Work? Natural Herbal Remedies For Erectile Dysfunction [url=http://proteahealth.info/pharma/viagra-up-all-night-2c.html]viagra up all night[/url] Erectile Dysfunction can affect you relation

Anonymous said...

Truly Peyronie???s Disease Obtain a Link with Male Erectile Dysfunction? Vitamins For Impotence Problems - A List Of Facts [url=http://aldara.in/pharmacy/keppra-medication-for-babies-b2.html]keppra medication for babies[/url] Buy Kamagra to Attend the issues of Erectile Dysfunction

Anonymous said...

Erectile Dysfunction (ED) Pills- Is Dropping Your Eyesight Really Worth The Risk? How Kegel Exercises Make Your Erectile Dysfunction Worse [url=http://bricomedical.info/pharmacy/viagra-vs-cialis-online-3d.html]viagra vs cialis online[/url] Erectile Dysfunction w Young Men: That Overview

Seacanoeist Mark said...

I liked your article, I will share your article to everyone!!




WoW gold|Diablo 3 Gold|RS Gold|Cheap Diablo 3 Gold

Seacanoeist Mark said...

I liked your article, I will share your article to everyone!!




WoW gold|Diablo 3 Gold|RS Gold|Cheap Diablo 3 Gold

Anonymous said...

This is a very good tip especially to those new to the blogosphere.
Brief but very accurate information… Appreciate your sharing this one.
A must read post!

my web site Henry Ford Edsel Ford Charles Sorensen Harry Bennett Rouge Factory Plant Highland Park Michigan Piquette Avenue Mack Detroit 1903 1904 1905 1906 1907 1908 1909 1910 1911 1912 1913 1914 1915 1916 1917 1918 1919 1920 1921 1922 1923 1924 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940 Model T A Flathead 4 banger Fred Black James Couzens Ernest Liebold Peter Martin Ray Dahlinger Evangeline Historic Fairlane Hospital Club John Roy Manning Historical Hospital 91 Manchester Roadster Touring Sedan Convertible A400 400A 40B 40A 35A 35A 35B 45B 55A 55B 68A 68B Pickup Truck Vintage Photo Photos Fair Lane Grosse Pointe Farm Farms Dearborn Heights Classic Car ger Antique Vintage Miller Road rd Gate 4 UAW Union Ruins Clara Ford Ford Bryan David Lewis Heritage Association Model A Restorers Club Restorers Ford Club America Early V-8 Club Antique Automobile Club E.T. Gregorie Eugene Farkas Lawrence Sheldrick Phaeton Touring Tudor Fordor Town Robert Lacey Steven Watts Allan Allen Nevins Sidney Olson Floyd Clymer Lorin Sorensen Rouge Park Capitalist Industry News Dealer Dealership Cote Race Brass Nickel nickle Survivor William Ford Alan Mullaly Mullally Albert Kahn Shenango Buffalo Jacksonville San Diego Richmond San Francisco Seattle New York Atlanta Georgia California Washington Seattle Richmond Hill Ways Savannah Restoration Restore NOS Parts Frank Campsall William Cameron Ten Eyck Dearborn Country Club Barrett-Jackson Barrett Jackson Baret BarretJackson Kruse Auction Russo Steele Mecum Florida Model T International Fort Myers Estero Everglades Preservation AACA MARC MAFCA MTFCA MTFCI Region Chapter Service Early EEE Building POEE Powertrain Archive History Facts Figures Production Numbers Ford Land Fairlane Falcon Torino Mainline 1946 1947 1948 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 Customline Sunliner Victoria Phaeton Country squire Woody wagon Station Administration Engineer Engineering Design Prototype Houdaille Shock Absorbers Barn Fresh Field Find Artifacts Kansas City Missouri Cincinnati Ohio Green Island Nankin Mills River Raisin Edward Cutler Super Duty F150 F250 F350 F550 F650 F750 F1 F2 F3 F5 F100 B Building Hyatt Hotel Shopping Center Rotunda Worlds Fair Worlds Chicago Illinois Fordbarn Ford Barn Ahooga Museum List Village Industries Thomas Edison Institute Greenfield Village Museum

Anonymous said...

I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but
your sites really nice, keep it up! I'll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back in the future. Many thanks

Have a look at my homepage http://autismforsocialnetwork2.speedysarcade.net/mukobytwore605
Also see my website: charlock

Anonymous said...

Υour post offеrs verified useful tο mе.

It’s extremelу helρful аnd you are naturally really educated in thiѕ areа.
Υοu poѕsess opened up my eye to be able to varying oρinion of
this subject together wіth interesting anԁ strong written cоntent.
My web-site klonopin

Anonymous said...

This will increase circulation of blood by the penis and so on.
Is it really true you can reverse impotence naturally if you are 65 decades old.
Doctors can help cure erectile dysfunction by injection erection stimulating medicine on
the base of the penis.

Have a look at my website ... Buy Viagra Cheap

Anonymous said...

A lot of loan applications by individuals with bad credit are
rejected by lending institutions. With a bad credit payday loan
it is made for individuals with bad credit and practically everyone is accepted.


Review my homepage Payday Loans

jake lee said...




Well done girls, I've runescape gold often wondered where all rs gold this newfangled blogging would get you buy runescape gold and there you Aion Kinah Kaufen are, large as wow gold life (well larger than postage stamp size anyway) on the front page of The Times. Congratulations on being cheap runescape gold their best blog for family cooking.

He was
hurt in the first GW2 Gold quarter of Tuesdays win over thee
Philadelphia 76ers.

Anonymous said...

The strength of keyword research not just lies in having the
finest devices but also the abilities that you have.
It is a ability that is obtained with time. The major
determining aspect on the option of the finest research device is whether your advertising method
is PPC or natural search engine position. The Google Keyword
device is one of the most popular keyword research tools that we can ever before have and it
is a well designed tool for the purpose of keyword research since it also
helps to estimate the quantity of traffic that frequents a keyword using the
keyword website traffic estimator. Many significantly
is the function that the Google Keyword device
plays in the establishing the Google AdWords Campaigns. If you are using the Google AdWords for marketing your company you
will discover Google keyword device to be the very best tool for
this task.

Some of the best info about Overture Keyword Tool can be discovered by visiting
this webpage- Overture Keyword Tool.