Sunday 11 July 2010

Forms of Power

A post here just got a very interesting comment. I'm going to reproduce it here, and then make a few comments of my own.
"Why do we condemn the patriarchy if not for the fact that it is a power imbalance? What theoretical footing can feminism have if it is not the rejection of power imbalances?"

A frame of reference I have found useful is the distinction between a "rational and temporary" imbalance of power and an "irrational and permanent" one. For example, as the parent of a child, I held a "rational and temporary" imbalance of power vis-a-vis my daughter which derived from my greater understanding and mastery of many aspects of the environment and my responsibility for getting her safely to the point where her knowledge and mastery allowed her to function independently. It was an imbalance intended to come to an end, a goal for which I bore - in my very power - a great deal of responsibility for achieving. My daughter is now in her late 20s, and we both work hard to weed out the last remnants of that old, once-rational-but-now-outdated imbalance in order to achieve the *balance* of power that is more appropriate to two adults in relationship.

The context in which I learned this way of distinguishing two types of power was that of the therapist-client relationship. As a radical feminist practicing psychotherapy, one of my main concerns was to acknowledge and play my part as one whose experience and expertise placed me in the position of having greater power in a way that guaranteed its "rational and temporary" nature. Everything I did was ultimately in the service of shifting that power balance so that ultimately my client and I would be in a relationship in which our power was equal.
++++++++++++
A second concept which has served me well has been the distinction between "power-over" and "power-as-personal-potency." Patriarch only has one concept of power; it is synonymous with "domination," or "power-over." Feminism (re-)introduces another form of power, that of "potency," which does not require the subservience of another in order to exist. When the personal power/potency of all parties is a 'given,' then an exploration of power-as-domination, it seems to me, can have an entirely new reality.
I honestly can't tell whether this commenter is pro-SM or anti-SM. She mentions being a radical feminist, and most of those I've met are anti-, but there's a difference between speaking of a group and speaking of an individual. So I'm not sure.

But I like the idea of "rational and temporary." When I was studying Wartenberg on power, he spoke of two different kinds of power as well. He called the sort of power that a good parent or good teacher has over a child "transformative power." His analysis is very similar to the commenter's here: this power is intended to be wielded temporarily, and intended to phase itself out over time as the child develops her own control over her life.

I like that very much as a base for talking about why healthy D/s isn't abusive and has nothing to do with patriarchy. Still, it's not perfect. Obviously, participants in consensual BDSM are not children, and most D/s is not intentionally set up to change over time. (Of course, being realistic, we should recognize that it actually will -- no power dynamic is ever completely static.) It's certainly not intended to bring about its own obsolescence. So opponents of D/s could make the argument that it's not the same thing.

The thing is, I don't think that all of us magically outgrow relations in which concensual hierarchy or consensual power dynamics exist. Yes, most of us leave school at some point in our lives, but plenty of us still learn things, take classes, put ourselves under the informal tutelage of friends. We all have limitations, things that others we know do better than we do. We all have situations in which we want to be sheltered and comforted, and to lose ourselves at least in the illusion that a more powerful loved one can protect us. We all -- I hope -- have situations arise in which others respect us as trusted authorities too, whether as wise bosses, senior members of organizations, or even just good givers of advice.

Which leads me to see power relations in which one person has more power than another as quite natural and, much of the time, rather unremarkable and boring. Hence my confusion when people of a "radical" bent want to shine a spotlight on "how power works" and throw most of it out, envisioning a more "egalitarian" (so it's termed, anyway) world.

And when we get to BDSM, or to D/s specifically, I blink. It's right to worry about the potential for abuse, just as it's right to be careful when using a knife or lighting a fire. Those things can harm you, or even kill you.

But the fact that they are dangerous does not make them so terrifying they're no longer useful. We could choose not to use a knife or a match and still live a perfectly productive and interesting life, though we might have to make some interesting adaptations. So if radical feminists want to try and eradicate as much hierarchy as they can from their lives, that's fine with me. It's just like the person who goes through some interesting convolutions because she's scared of knives. It's none of my business.

But when someone goes on a crusade against knives, saying that we can hurt ourselves with them, or mentioning that sometimes they're used in violence or homicide, that's when I roll my eyes and decide that someone's being truly unreasonable. It's not someone else's choice what risks someone else takes, especially when their own life is structured to avoid risk in a way that most of the rest of us would never do. No, it doesn't make the rest of us right that we all do the same thing -- hundred thousand lemmings can be wrong -- but the simple point that the knife is dangerous does not thereby prove that none of us should be using them.

Or that if we do use them, we should see this as a regrettable, necessary evil that stems only from the fact that our society has not yet advanced to the point where we can cut food without sharp things. That we should see enjoying cutting our vegetables as some sort of sign that we're inherently broken, damaged by abuse, or possessing "false consciousness" taught to us by a culture invested in selling us Ginsu knives.

When we grow and become adults, hopefully one tool we develop is discernment in the power relations we enter into. Some of us, of course, will not do this -- and sometimes the most fine-honed discernment in the world is useless in the face of a sufficiently charming con artist, deceiver, or abuser. But the mere fact that some of us don't have discernment, or that we can be bamboozled by the cruel and unethical, does not mean those of us who do should be told not to use it.

And that's the thing that gets me in all this, really. The society that many anti-SM people envision as Utopia is built for the lowest common denominator: no sharp edges. No matches. No knives. The poor, poor women could get hurt!

Perhaps I'm wicked for this, but I don't believe we build a successful and healthy society by choosing the maximum level of protection and telling the smartest and wisest they'll just have to suck it up and not take risks so as not to confuse the vulnerable. Protecting the vulnerable is important, but that should be done in a nuanced way. That should not be done by forcing the rest of us to live tapioca lives because someone who doesn't understand might see, might see!

That's the thing. I do believe people have some responsibility for other people seeing and emulating their behavior, but I don't think "think of the women!" is any less disgusting than the kind of "think of the children!" that forgets that thoughtful children, when engaged in deep and age-appropriate discussions of the world around them, can actually understand a lot of things.

Besides, I'm female. I don't want people protecting me because they're "thinking of me." I don't want people protecting my partner from me without, you know, at least saying three words to her first. I want a fulfilling life with my partner that includes the kinds of dynamics she and I choose for ourselves, thanks.

251 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 251 of 251
Anonymous said...

They may be also shade coded as outlined by the delivered excess
weight chart on your ease.

Take a look at my blog post - dog dumbbells

Anonymous said...

What i do not understood is in truth how you're no longer really a lot more well-preferred than you might be now. You are very intelligent. You recognize therefore significantly in the case of this topic, made me personally imagine it from so many various angles. Its like men and women are not involved except it's something
to do with Girl gaga! Your individual stuffs excellent. Always
deal with it up!

Feel free to visit my web site gamersadda.org

Anonymous said...

Marketplace studies have shown that, 1 from every five people own personal a two wheeler. chwilówki ;> There are many items that can be incorrect when departing the nation and people providing within HM Armed Forces travelling abroad regularly might do well to be ready and take advantage of the unique guidelines available. A lot of people think that they cannot require insurance plan because nothing may happen for them, but it is always preferable to end up being safe compared to sorry. There is no way of telling whenever some thing unpredicted will take place like a loss of package or private possessions within transportation or any sort of accident whilst away from responsibility needing hospitalization if you choose not need the price to become a problem if it is not really getting included in the particular M. U. Deb.
chwilówki szybko dla każdego In case a home owner selects to use the home being a rental home, a typical home insurance policy is not adequate. Particular insurance plan is required to offer safety towards damage and liability as a result of renting the home. This consists of renting the whole house and also simply hiring away an area in your home.

Anonymous said...

four. Factor. In times where several insurance providers is definitely covering a particular risk, if a reduction occurred, the insurance providers must contribute towards the settlement of the state according to their rateable proportion.
chwilówki ;<

Whatever you must know about PLPD car insurance PLPD car insurance refers to personal liability (PL) plus property damage (PD) insurance. PLPD insurance fulfills the state minimum amount needs to use an automobile on the road. It is very important remember, however , it doesn't include comprehensive or even crash insurance coverage. PLPD auto insurance is generally a great fit for individuals generating an old car, people with extreme points on their permit, or those simply with limited funds. In depth and impact insurance options add substantial price to an auto insurance plan. That is why a basic PLPD auto insurance policy without these coverage options can be so inexpensive.
pożyczki pozabankowe Twoje 30 dni

Anonymous said...

These come inside of a few of distinct fat
variances.

Also visit my page - Report abuse

Anonymous said...

The bottom line is this; you're truly worth some time and energy it will consider to become healthful and match.

my webpage bowflex selecttech dumbbells

Anonymous said...

The advantage of exploring online is usually, you will discover all insurance providers with one particular place -- you can travel to those sites of the insurance companies to know various kinds of insurance plan products they offer, the highlights of each product, program procedure, superior for different products and so on. Thus, you will discover life and non-life insurance plan products along with varying ideals, with functions such as accident/disability riders, etc . levitra oznaki Exactly where are you able to purchase PLPD Auto insurance? Thanks to technologies as well as the rise of the web shopping for an inexpensive PLPD insurance coverage is never easier. Comparing prices and shopping around was once a pain. It involved producing numerous telephone calls and speaking with the half number of sales reps and insurance companies. Of course additionally you had to pay attention to every sales rep place in their own two pennies and make a sales pitch. Luckily, periods have changed and you understand longer have to do issues the old-fashioned way. Now you can compare quotations as well as purchase PLPD auto insurance from the particular convenience of your home. When it is your own objective to get the least expensive price possible for PLPD insurance plan I suggest going online and visiting an online insurance comparison site. These sites will make your life simple. They are going to inquire a person several easy queries like your go code as well as the type of automobile you generate. When you have provided this information the comparison web site will provide you with a listing of the particular carriers inside your zip code with the most affordable prices. Once you have concentrated lower your choice you are able to full your quote with all the carrier of the choice plus complete your purchase on the internet or with a live consultant. Wazne strony Find out more about the Auto Insurance Professional as well as the Greatest Car insurance Companies in Torbett Auto Source nowadays. Przeczytaj

Anonymous said...

Quality value Belongings Pobierz Wiecej informacji With so many advertisements about various programs and guidelines all over the place, it can obtain puzzling to comprehend exactly what it is that is right for you. But understanding the best plan for means that you must understand exactly what insurance coverage is. What exactly is it that you should know about insurance coverage? Life insurance coverage is, extremely just, an awareness in your way on the path to the life span insurance provider: a person accept pay out a specific amount to the business every month as well as the business agrees to pay the final amount for your family or even nominee after your dying. All in all, you will get the particular comfort that the household is going to be a minimum of financially secure should something occur to you. Various businesses offer you various life insurance plans. Several plans might be term programs '" which is for the fixed number of years; as well as others could be life programs '" which is, till the day time a person pass away. Each plan demands you to definitely pay out a premium for that plan which you buy. You have the option of having to pay the premium with an annual foundation as well '" which can help you save the trouble associated with regular pointers. cialis na wakacje Doggy Attacks cialis sprawdza sie

Anonymous said...

Article writing is also a fun, if you be familiar with afterward you can write otherwise it is complicated
to write.

Also visit my site ... exercises to jump higher

Anonymous said...

Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that
automatically tweet my newest twitter updates. I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

Review my page - Full Piece of writing

Anonymous said...

Uninsured Motorist Protection: addresses accidents triggered to you or maybe the various other residents of your car by uninsured or even hit-and-run drivers. sprawdz moje zrodlo Take advantage of discount rates. Numerous insurance firms possess good driver discounts, car protection feature discounts and discounts with regard to non-smokers and consumers. pożyczki bez bik What to look for within a health insurance program chwilówka
http://www.facefook.ir/blog/82659/kredyty-szybka-chwilowka/
http://pattersonsheridan.com/index.php/member/91331/

Anonymous said...

Just before selecting a plan from the private medical health insurance service provider, you should determine what your present insurance coverage covers so you decide exactly what extra insurance you need. Too, be sure you check out any kind of exclusions in your current policy that will inform you what is not really covered. The particular goal should be getting insurance coverage which will offset high cost health care providers. kredyt bez bik Twoje 30 dni four. Contribution. In a situation exactly where several insurance providers is usually addressing a particular risk, in case a reduction happened, the insurance providers must contribute towards the settlement of the state according to their own rateable percentage. chwilówka Liability security is provided in most home owners insurance plans. If you occur to get sued from the individual bitten from your dog, you happen to be still included in your insurance. But any harm to your house inflicted by your household pets will not be protected. If your prized area rug is definitely destroyed by your pet, the insurance business is not going to include the expense of replacing the carpet. przydatne zasoby
http://www.tramaweb.com.br/blog/index.php/2010/11/01/onde-foi-parar-a-privacidade/comment-page-1/
http://www.releaseteam.com/member/64738

Anonymous said...

Intereѕting blog! Is your theme custom made oг did you
download it from someωhеre? A theme like yours with а
fеw ѕimρle adjustements woulԁ геаlly make my blоg jump
out. Рlease let me κnoω where уou got your dеsign.

Thanκ you

Herе is my blog hcg drops

Anonymous said...

opgcu0vu

d6j3t577

f54yewr4t536

onwzui1q

ti5dvj9q

Anonymous said...

Howdy! I could have sworn I've visited this blog before but after looking at some of the articles I realized it's new to me.
Anyways, I'm definitely happy I discovered it and I'll be book-marking it
and checking back often!

My page exercises to improve vertical leap

Anonymous said...

It's going to also lower your recovery time, stop accidents, and cause you to a much better, greater athlete.

Take a look at my site http://www.getfitnstrong.com/bowflex-dumbbells/bowflex-selecttech-dumbbells-ultimate-home-exercising/

Anonymous said...

In this Terrell Owens bands review we have discussed exactly anything you get with this product or service, you also
learned with regards to the instruction and support that they
deliver you soon after the sale and ultimately we have discussed the exciting new name for this fitness tubes property health
club.

Here is my homepage ... getfitnstrong.com

Anonymous said...

With numerous accessories for example water bottles, bottle cages, seat pads, and education videos to complement your Nautilus equipment, working
on cardio capacity and muscle mass health and fitness becomes a pleasure!


Feel free to visit my web site :: modells dumbbells

Anonymous said...

Organs such as kidney, liver and even our eyes play an important role of 7 day cleanse detoxification of the human body.
As you look out for 7 Day Cleanse Detox programs, ranging in price, out there.

Couch grass also helps soothe and reverse inflammation in urinary tract.


my web-site - Webpage

Anonymous said...

Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article.

I will make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information.
Thanks for the post. I will certainly return.

Visit my web page iesjoanfustersueca.edu.gva.es

Anonymous said...

This page truly has all the information I wanted about this subject and didn't know who to ask.

Feel free to surf to my web blog; candy crush saga hack

Anonymous said...

Do you have a spam problem on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation;
we have created some nice practices and we are looking
to trade strategies with other folks, please shoot me an
e-mail if interested.
munich germany
munich germany
munich germany
munich germany
munich germany
http://173-254-66-136.unifiedlayer.com/elementary-fine-points-part-social-media-services-and-marketing.
html
http://163.27.151.1/~yst/phpBB2021/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=734513
http://209-20-69-40.slicehost.net/node/3702
http://2009.desurasur.org/content/get-most-desirable-strategies-social-media-marketing
http://2consumer.com/books-music-movies/incorporate-twitter-followers-nice-popularity

Here is my web page: munich germany

Anonymous said...

It can also cause priapism problem revitol stretch mark cream review solved!
There's no treatment for either disease. Passion flower is used for treating skin conditions such as acne, psoriasis, balanitis, or a simple skin condition, an important factor in reducing this risk. Cleansing the foreskin of an uncircumcised male developing penile cancer is fairly rare. She strives to create a rhythmic pattern. Exercising 30 minutes a day.

Here is my weblog :: revitolstretchmarkcreamreviews.Net

Anonymous said...

Ιt's remarkable to pay a quick visit this web page and reading the views of all colleagues concerning this article, while I am also eager of getting experience.

Stop by my web blog; lloyd irvin

Anonymous said...

Hey I know thiѕ is off topic but I was wondering if you knеw of any widgets I could add to
my blog that аutomаtically tωeеt my newest twitter uρdateѕ.
I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

My homepage twitter.com

Anonymous said...

They readily fold up and deal with extremely very little area.


Here is my website - dumbbells for sale

Anonymous said...

Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site,
how could i subscribe for a weblog web site? The account helped me a applicable deal.
I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided vivid clear idea

Here is my page; novostar gngen

Anonymous said...

With all the buzz and exhilaration bordering their infomercials it
would make you surprise whether or not they truly function.



My webpage: bowflex dumbbells 552

Anonymous said...

Essentially the most realistic and convenient instrument I have uncovered to receive adult females toned up quick is the
Bowflex SelectTech 552 Dumbbells.

my webpage bowflex selecttech dumbbells

Anonymous said...

It's difficult to find experienced people on this topic, but you seem like you know what you're talking
about! Thanks

Feel free to visit my web blog :: book of ra online spielen echtgeld

Anonymous said...

free transexual dating website http://loveepicentre.com/ online dating service for married people
free christian dating sights [url=http://loveepicentre.com/advice/]free dating sites anywhere in michigan[/url] tallahassee dating forum
morgan freem an dating granddaughter [url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles/]dating single mom[/url] dating after 44 [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/kings/]kings[/url] african amercian phone dating services

Anonymous said...

Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as
though you relied on the video to make your point. You clearly
know what youre talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting videos to
your blog when you could be giving us something informative to read?



Here is my blog - Psn Code Generator

Anonymous said...

You is now able to deep clean those pores and also renew skin growth in an eco-friendly way.
) White Willow Bark is known is unclog pores and fight acne.

Dermatologists and alternative medicine practitioners advise that acne-sufferers should wash
the location twice daily with mild soap. Although many people believe
that the proper way of washing the face is with hot or warm water,
I have found the opposite being true.

Check out my website :: acne 6Dpo

Anonymous said...

If your house sustains damage brought on by pestssuch as pests (termites), molds, and vermin (rats and squirrels)your homeowners insurance plan will never protect the price of maintenance. Stopping this type of harm from occurring is viewed as the obligation of the property owner. Thus, it will help to consider time investigating regarding typical pests, such as the early indications that suggest their presence as well as the actions you can take to eliminate them prior to they will cause additional damage. pożyczki pozabankowe Suggestions associated with prior clients chwilówka przez internet The advantage of exploring on-line will be, you will find all insurers at one place : you can visit those sites from the insurers to learn various kinds of insurance policy products they offer, the particular popular features of each item, program procedure, high quality for different products and the like. Therefore, you could find life and non-life insurance items along with changing beliefs, with functions such as accident/disability riders, and so forth kredyty chwilówki
http://js360viewer.com/forum/index.php?p=/discussion/192/szybka-pozyczka-w-nag%C2%B3ych-przypadkach

Anonymous said...

sex dating pussy http://loveepicentre.com/ j cafe dating site
dating headlock [url=http://loveepicentre.com/contact/]corpus christi speed dating[/url] trix dating female
dating for orlando executives [url=http://loveepicentre.com/faq/]springfield missouri dating[/url] dcapper dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/willsondaniel73/]willsondaniel73[/url] interracial dating in quebec canada

Anonymous said...

Time Frame viagra pigulki one Insurable attention. This is actually the monetary or even financial interest how the owner or even owner associated with home has within the subject-matter associated with insurance plan. The simple fact that it could be harmful in order to your pet ought to the reduction occurred because of their economic risk in this assets gives your pet the ability to ensure the home. Castellin Versus Preston 1886. kamagra na recepte Insurance providers could supply you with a policy which usually looks cheap when it comes to premiums yet provides practically nothing in the way of advantages plus discounts. A good example of this would be an absolutely no claims bonus. The zero states reward is really a cash return incentive the organization pays a person for not making promises on the insurance policy throughout a particular time period. It might be in the form of the one time or even by means of a lower on your upcoming monthly premiums. cialis modne

Anonymous said...

If Delhi, Mumbai and Bangalore are high in the grade
of business and commerce then Kolkata is much superior in catering the quality education in India.
The word, all that is said and taught belongs to Him.
The speaker, Tariq Ramadan, was once banned from entering the United
States.

Look into my web page :: islamic resources for teachers

Anonymous said...

Hey there! This is my first visit to youг blog!
We are a group of volunteers аnd startіng a new
initiativе in a сommunity іn the same niche.
Your blog proviԁеd us usеful іnformation to work
on. Yοu hаve done а extraorԁinary jоb!


my weblog ... pure green coffee bean 800mg

Anonymous said...

I was instructed by a coach after that, "Everything works, but almost nothing works for incredibly long.

Feel free to visit my web-site Powerblock Dumbbells Review

Anonymous said...

"I went outside this morning in the daylight without having makeup and my face still red and some scabbing onto it to walk 2 blocks to the mailbox. The following liquid soap recipes don't include lye or require any special equipment or ingredients. Don't make it too hot, but don't allow it get too cool. Another preventative the answer to take isn't wearing oily cosmetics at all or on rare occasion.

Feel free to visit my webpage ... foam acne wash

Anonymous said...

I think this is among the most important info for me.
And i am glad reading your article. But wanna remark on some general things, The web site style is ideal, the
articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers

Also visit my web site: lose weight quick

Anonymous said...

Also take into account the type of ring you are looking for.

People are still talking about it today, even though
she has had a whole new set of commitment rings (commitment,
not wedding, people) with Brad Pitt. Having never bought Wal-Mart jewelry, I assumed that I would receive the same high quality product as
before.

Check out my web site ... promise Rings dublin

Dich tieng nhat said...

It's difficult to find experienced people on this topic, but you seem like you know what you're talking
about! Thanks

Anonymous said...

We stumbled over here by a different web address and thought I should check things out.
I like what I see so i am just following you.

Look forward to checking out your web page repeatedly.

Look at my webpage :: muscle building foods

BDSM dating personals network said...

love the blog article!

Great analogy re knives!

Sir said...

Thank you for an interesting read. I often wonder about the common conception that, for relationships to work, there needs to be complete equality. On paper it sounds logical. In reality, I've never found it to be so. What is 'natural'? I doubt more and more that there is a one size fits all answer.

web lol said...

kul post

social media China said...

HI Hello to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is getting more from this site, and your views are pleasant for new people.

Anonymous said...

cheap runescape gold
gold rs

Richard Ressinger said...

Couldn't agree more with the comment, people should make their own decisions about risks they're willing to take. Too bad a few nutjobs hijacked the political discourse and turned it heavily in favor of protection versus opportunity, it is saddening to see this. What does make me feel better is the fact that at least I can get cheap runescape gold, otherwise society seems to be going down the drain.

Cadencealida said...

Poe orbs is an item required by all players on the Path of Exile. Since Poe does not have gold coins, Poe orbs have replaced the status of gold coins to a certain extent. Generally speaking, the way players obtain Poe orbs includes monsters, boxes, etc. However, these methods have a common disadvantage. They require players to spend a lot of time, and there are duplicates in loot. Buy POE Currency at POECurrency.com can effectively solve this problem and help players get a better gaming experience.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 251 of 251   Newer› Newest»